Why trading Dorian Finney-Smith does not make sense

Dorian Finney Smith is not an elite basketball player. But he’s the kind of role player elite teams hire. He is a strong defender who can hit three-pointers without asking for the ball. He is also very versatile from a defensive standpoint, as he has been tasked with guarding players in every position from base forward.

Smart teams evaluate each player based on the commercial value of their roster at any given moment. Finney-Smith is not good enough to be “non-tradable”. But the Mavericks should not trade it unless they get real value to it. The first trade mentioned in the above article is interesting due to the exploding Strus as a fling. However, one should always pay attention to the player development success stories that the Miami Heat would like to move on from.

The Heat are perhaps the best basketball team in both player development and player ratings. On the other hand, the Mavericks are not particularly good at either. Strus is not the same as replacing Vinnie Smith. He’s a shooter who isn’t a defender like Vinnie Smith. Moreover, Heat is unlikely to even make this trade. If they did, it would be a red flag for Strus.

The second trade introduced in this lot was Troy Brown Jr.’s Finney-Smith. And choose the second round. yak. Brown Jr. specifically does nothing on the basketball court and neither does Vinnie Smith. Missing Vinnie Smith some kicks from Luka Doncic bothering you? Brown Jr makes him look like the heyday of Klay Thompson. Vinnie Smith guarding the elite ocean scorers frustrate you? Brown makes him look like the pinnacle of Tony Allen’s defense. Brown is a better athlete than Vinnie Smith but a much worse basketball player. Round two picks are sold for cash each season. This would simply be the Finney-Smith trade for his trade.

The problem is that the kinds of teams that might be interested in Vinnie Smith are teams that are currently competing. Practically all of these teams exchanged all the assets they would be able to use to make the deal interesting for Dallas. Finney-Smith would be a great fit for the Utah Jazz for example, but they can’t trade a first-round pick until the end of the decade and likely aren’t interested in trading any of their core pieces.

The fact of the matter is that Finney-Smith is more valuable to the Mavericks than he would likely return him in a deal at this point. This team is good enough to be dangerous in the playoffs this season. Vinnie Smith is a big part of what makes her dangerous. Additionally, Finney-Smith is not likely to get a major contract as mentioned in the previous piece.

Finney-Smith and Tim Hardaway Jr are two completely different types of players. Hardaway Jr. restored his reputation to the point where he was seen as the capital’s shooter. Disputed, unchallenged, hold and shoot, pull, he can hit them all. He struggled with filming this year but that’s why he’s getting paid. Finney-Smith though improved filming over the past three years is more in line with Jae Crowder’s genres that are generally paid the mid-level exception.

At this price, Finney-Smith may not be an exceptional deal, but he certainly didn’t overcharge. Furthermore, while paying the luxury tax in order to keep Finney-Smith and Jalen Brunson seems unattractive, remember that Mark Cuban has made over $1 billion on the Mavericks through capital gains and actual revenue over the past decade while not paying the luxury tax never. The biggest concern for paying the tax is the limitations on the flexibility you place on future moves. But the Mavericks have been “keeping their powder dry” for a decade. Even dry powder eventually gets old.

If the right deal comes to Vinnie Smith, the Mavericks should totally consider it. But they should not be looking to trade it. His cheap contract now makes it difficult to deal with him for a lot of value due to CBA’s salary cap matching requirements.

The Mavericks should not look to trade it for the sole purpose of trading it. It wouldn’t be hard to trade Finney-Smith on anything that looked like a reasonable contract. Furthermore, if he gets a number that the Mavericks aren’t comfortable matching, they could potentially extract more value from their second-round pick through a sign and trade that would remain an option as long as he finished the season as the Mavericks. Finney-Smith is more attractive to the types of rival teams that don’t have much room to sign him in an exception deal that is directly above the mediocre.

Finally, not trading him, even if he doesn’t quit, allows him to play post-season with the Mavericks. No beast in the Western Conference this season besides the Phoenix Suns and Chris Paul has a history of not being able to hold out during the playoffs. The Mavericks have a well-developed defense and Luca has a history of absolute control of the offensive playoffs. Finney-Smith is the most rivalry among mavericks, and his trading would be a step backwards. As coach Herm Edwards once said “You play to win the game” and Vinnie Smith would not be trading for the win.

Leave a Comment